Visited by over 40 million consumers
Be Recommended on the #1 Independent Insurance Website
An Advantage subscription increases your digital footprint and gets you noticed by high-intent insurance prospects.
When the right insurance prospect is ready to buy, will they be able to find you?
Works like magic but really, it’s science.
First...
You customize your agency profile
Tell us about your agency and the business you want to write. Then, we feature you in our directory.
Meanwhile...
We bring in the prospects
Consumers looking for an agent are asked a few questions about their insurance needs.
Then...
Shoppers get recommended to you
Our recommendation engine matches your profile to the right shoppers and gets you connected.
There's an Advantage subscription to fit every agency size & need
Too busy for leads? You need Claim-it.
Our patent pending system sends you the prospects you want, exactly when you want them.
Why our referrals are better than leads
We deliver local, high-intent, appetite-matching prospects guaranteed to suit your preferred business appetite.
When a consumer requests to be contacted by an agency, we call that a referral. It is better than a lead because these prospects are:
- Inbound
- Real-Time
- Organic
- High-Intent
- Appetite-Matching
- Exclusive
Getting recommended is a huge deal, especially when it’s by a trusted source
As Featured In
Hundreds of happy independent agents have shared their stories
(here’s just a few!)
Rhode Island Agency Success Story – Chris Brook
https://youtu.be/igwJaanvj0w Chris Brook Brook Insurance Associates, LLC Warwick, RI “It’s nice to have organic growth. [TrustedChoice.com is] finding us people that my website isn’t - people that I can’t network to find.” “Sometimes we’re getting three and four...
Nebraska Agency Success Story – Phil Guenette
https://youtu.be/9StQCwKuCfE Phil Guenette Guardian IPS, LLC Twinsburg, OH “One of the commercial [referrals from TrustedChoice.com] was about a $9-10k annual premium.” “I really like [the Claim-it Referral Program]. I like that I get the text messages, and I can take...
Ohio Agency Success Story – Rob Strachan
https://youtu.be/2Vj5O3A5Ocw Rob Strachan Strachan-Novak Insurance Services LLC Twinsburg, OH “I think having the Trusted Choice listing and the reviews absolutely helps us really weed through the people that we want to do business with.” “In 2023, I believe we wrote...
Colorado Agency Success Story – Fred Lautenbach
https://youtu.be/JDozUWgzK4w Fred Lautenbach Lautenbach Insurance Agency, LLC Littleton, CO “We’ve had an account that we received through TrustedChoice.com that was very small at first… That premium I believe started at about $2500, and currently that premium sits a...
South Carolina Agency Success Story – Corbin Norton – Claim-it Series
https://youtu.be/h42zoarwHfk Corbin Norton Norton Insurance Agency Cheraw, SC “The Claim-it leads, number one, are way more affordable. You really have more control over how you tailor the appetite… It’s been the best system that I’ve ever worked with.” “My largest...
New York Agency Success Story – Keith Philipps
https://youtu.be/oEd1BxBNyWE Keith Philipps Schmutter, Strull, Fleisch Inc. New York, NY “The amount of premium that we’ve written far outweighs the cost – so the ROI is great… It’s a no-brainer.” “Per year, I would say [we bind] at least between $50,000-$200,000 in...
See more success stories
Recommended Reading
Mastering Digital Marketing in the Insurance Industry
In today’s complex digital landscape, knowing how to market your business online is essential for consistent growth — especially for the independent insurance agent. With the right tools and strategies, independent agents can level the competitive playing ground,...
Trusted Insurance Markets for Your Personal Lines Prospects
Spring gives rise to the busiest time of year for personal insurance. This means you may be looking for new market providers for your clients and prospects. To get your season off to a good start, we pulled together our list of insurance company partners who are ready...
What Are High-Intent Insurance Prospects and How Can I Attract Them to My Agency?
Targeting the right prospects is key to the success of any business — including independent insurance agencies. Although it may be tempting to prioritize quantity over quality when it comes to insurance leads (in hopes that sheer numbers will yield results for your...