When insurance shoppers search for an agent on TrustedChoice.com, where does your agency rank? Your position in search results can make a huge difference in how many prospects find and contact you. But what determines your ranking, and how can you optimize your profile to stand out?
At TrustedChoice.com, we use two primary sorting methods:
- Best Match: Prioritizes agencies based on a Relevance Score, which factors in profile strength, reviews, business appetite, and more.
- Distance: Helps shoppers find agents closest to them.
While you can’t change your physical location, you have full control over your Relevance Score—a key factor in climbing search results and attracting more ideal clients.
Want to boost your agency’s ranking? Follow these five key steps to maximize visibility and turn your profile into a powerful lead magnet.
1) Complete Your Profile (Every Detail Matters!)
Think of your profile as your digital storefront. A weak or incomplete profile won’t inspire confidence, while a fully optimized one sets you apart from competitors.
- Fill out your contact details
- List all your services
- Add team members to your directory
- Upload a professional logo
- Write a compelling ‘About Us’ section
Pro Tip: Agencies with fully completed profiles rank significantly higher! Follow this guide to ensure you’re maximizing your visibility.
2) Location Matters—But a Strong Profile Wins
While proximity influences ranking, it’s not the only factor. Even if you’re not the closest agency, a well-optimized profile can outperform those nearby.
Think about it this way: Consumers will drive past one grocery store to shop at a better one. The same applies to choosing an insurance agency!
3) Collect and Showcase Customer Reviews
More reviews = More trust = Higher rankings.
Consumers rely on reviews to make decisions. Encourage happy clients to leave detailed, authentic testimonials about their experience with your agency.
- Reach out to satisfied customers and ask for feedback
- Respond to reviews to show engagement
- The more high-quality reviews, the better your ranking!
4) Fine-Tune Your Risk Appetite for Better Matches
Your business appetite settings determine the types of clients you attract. Keeping them updated and accurate ensures you get matched with prospects that fit your agency’s expertise.
Need help updating your appetite settings? Here’s how.
5) Maximize Carrier Appointments to Strengthen Your Profile
The more carriers you’re appointed with—especially those aligned with consumer demand—the stronger your ranking.
- List all your appointed carriers
- Make sure they match consumer needs
- More appointments = Higher Relevance Score
Understanding Product Tiers: Where Does Your Agency Fit?
To help consumers find the best agents, TrustedChoice.com categorizes agencies into tiers:
Tier 1: Matching Specialist Agencies—These agencies specialize in specific industries or lines of business and operate in broader geographic areas. They receive premium ad placements and top visibility. Interested in becoming a specialist? Contact us!
Tier 2: Matching Advantage Professional & Preferred Agencies—Agencies in this tier receive equal prioritization in consumer searches.
Take Control of Your Ranking—Start Optimizing Today!
Your agency’s ranking isn’t set in stone—you have the power to improve it. By optimizing your profile, gathering more reviews, and fine-tuning your business appetite, you can increase your visibility and attract more ideal prospects.
Need help optimizing your profile? Our team is here to assist. Let’s connect and help your agency thrive!
